Floating Town and Royal Docks – a good idea or a waste of water?

At a recent international property conference in Cannes (MIPIM), Boris Johnson announced a major competition to design and develop a large floating development on the water at London’s Royal Victoria Docks.

http://www.standard.co.uk/news/london/boris-island-2-plan-for-floating-docks-village-8531083.html

My first thought was ‘another ill thought through gimmick’ (perhaps like the Cable Car where I played ‘spot the passenger’ one day last week before going to a conference on Singapore and its approach to Smart City Growth).

Image

But my next thought was ‘Why not? What do you do with a vast expanse of water which was a dock?.  You could use it for some sort of water based sporting activity, or a marina perhaps, but I think that the former tends to be space hungry for the benefit of a few people as well as potentially anti-social if the activity is power based, and the latter invariably looks a mess and is in reality a car park for boats most of the time. Other ways of dealing with disused docks in the past have also included filling them in and building on top of the newly created site, but to me this a waste of something which we could not afford to create nowadays.

So, a floating village of homes and places of entertainment, if of high quality, could be an inspired use for such a large space of open water. But is there such a shortage of open space and available development sites in the Royal Docks that we have to build on the water? The answer to this question is ‘No’: there is plenty of room at the Royal Docks so why build on water? Why not retain the open expanses of water as a foil to the high density development which will be build around the old docks, and to provide beautiful vistas and light effects with the sky and light being reflected in the glassy calm water and provide a sense of space?

Image

So, in the end I think that it is best not to build on the water when there is plenty of space surrounding it, unless building on the water allows other sites to be made-over to public open space and parks which otherwise would not be provided due to lack of space – although high density development such as proposed for the Royal’s ought to have public parks and space designed in from the beginning anyway.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Floating Town and Royal Docks – a good idea or a waste of water?

  1. Adam Roake says:

    Hi Steven,

    Did you see this on earlier in the week (about 12mins in)? http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b01rb3mc/The_Culture_Show_2012_2013_Episode_28/

    Not sure if it’s linked to Boris’ announcement but it seems to set the tone. I rather agree with you though that it might be sensible to use up the hectares of derelict land before resorting to building on the water!

    • stevenboxall says:

      Hello Adam,

      I did see the Culture Show and, yes, the bit about floating homes and development did end up talking about a proposal for the Royal Docks in East London, and it must be too much of a coincidence not to be linked with Boris’ announcement.

      In the end I suspect that this is just a way of gaining publicity for east London at MIPIM rather than anything which will happen anytime soon, although it is a shame if London needs a publicity stunt to get attention.

      I have no real objection to the idea in itself if it is about space creation and/or place making, but there is plenty of available space around The Royal Docks, and the open water there should help to create the place. I think it was a bit silly of the presenter on The Culture Show to talk about a land shortage in the context of this location.

      When I was working in Ashford, on its Growth Plan, we put forward the concept of a ‘Canal District’ as a piece of place making and urban design, and we did get a visit from a Dutch architect to talk about floating homes.

  2. Pingback: London’s Royal Docks – Floating Developments | Regeneration X Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s